Sections

Weather Forecast

Close

Other View: Twin Metals bill should be blocked

The U.S. House recently passed legislation that would not only reopen the possibility of copper-nickel mining on the edge of the Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness but would hamstring the government's ability to prevent that possibility.

It should go no further.

The "MINER" Act, sponsored by U.S. Rep. Tom Emmer, R-Delano, would reinstate two expired mineral licenses in the Superior National Forest that were held by Twin Metals, a subsidiary of Chilean mining giant Antofagasta. The administration of President Barack Obama declined to extend those licenses and instead initiated a lengthy environmental review of the effects of copper-nickel mining in that area. The bill also would squash that review.

But it goes further and prohibits the government from ever conducting such a review in Minnesota (and in Minnesota only) without specific congressional authorization.

It should be noted that, unlike the PolyMet debate, there is no specific mining proposal by Twin Metals. The PolyMet mine, if it is approved, would be in a different watershed. Gov. Mark Dayton, who has made water quality a hallmark issue of his administration, has endorsed the PolyMet proposal but opposes Twin Metals.

Emmer's bill cleared the House by a slender 12 votes, and the state delegation split 4-4, more along geographic lines than partisan lines. Tim Walz, the DFLer who represents southern Minnesota's 1st District and is running for governor, voted no.

Sen. Amy Klobuchar has been silent on the issue, and Emmer hopes to get her on board.

Mining has become a tricky issue for Minnesota's Democrats, who typically rely both on votes from the Iron Range and from environmental activists. The demand for mining jobs and the need to protect our valued wilderness areas are increasingly in conflict, and the Emmer bill emphatically comes down in favor of the former. The needle should be threaded with more care and with less rigidity than it would establish.

Advertisement